This Book Is Overdue!
Below are the highlights from some of the great reviews.
THE NEW YORK TIMES BOOK REVIEW featured Overdue in a wonderful review by Pagan Kennedy. She describes my search for a half-remembered passage about information overload, then writes: "If Johnson herself displays symptoms of information sickness, she has a glorious form of the disease." She calls the book fascinating, and declares that "Johnson writes best when she’s meandering and browsing, in the manner of a woozy reader exploring the stacks. In her most absorbing passages, I felt as if I were back in the children’s library, scrutinizing a volume of the World Book Encyclopedia, where the entry on 'pachyderm' sat near the disquisition on 'pachysandra,' a kind of ground cover. Johnson’s book carries the same kind of associative magic. Rather than taking us on a brisk, orderly march, she lets us ride on the swaying back of an elephant, glimpsing treasures glimmering through the fronds of pachysandra." Read more.
The information service RESOURCE SHELF covered Overdue with enthusiasm, and in a post announcing my SALON.COM interview, declared: "Once again, Johnson does an amazing job answering [questions]. She should be the keynote speaker at just about every library related conference and then hired to work for each of those organizations as their marketing director." Read more.
USA TODAY called it "a humorous, unabashed love letter to the men and women who used to toil quietly in stacks but now circulate in cyberspace" in an important article by Craig Wilson about the perilous state of American libraries. Read more.
Kim Schmidt of the CHICAGO SUN-TIMES wrote,"Johnson makes it clear that she was always a lover of libraries, but that she became inspired to write about them when she was researching her earlier, brilliantly written book on obituary writers, The Dead Beat. 'With the exception of a few showy eccentrics … the most engaging obit subjects were librarians. I began to get the idea that libraries were where it was happening.' And happening it is." She concludes this dream review: "With this joyful and absorbing look into the world of librarians, Johnson has filled a desperately needed gap in our understanding, and she will inspire her readers to feel as she does: thank goodness for librarians." Read more.
“When I started at the library, saying you disliked technology was still acceptable. By the time I left, that admission would earn you a pitying, not to say incredulous, look," wrote librarian Tricia Springstubb in THE PLAIN DEALER. "Marilyn Johnson gets all this and more...She pays homage to a profession undergoing a mind-boggling transition...
"This cheerful book is full of personalities...[and] Johnson doesn't skimp on the trials of faltering computer systems, or the gross things patrons can leave on the shelves...Chances are good that if you read this book, it'll be a library copy. When you return it, even if it's overdue, smile at that nice person behind the desk.” Read more.
“Ms. Johnson's enthusiasm for libraries and the people who work in them is refreshingly evident throughout the book," stated Christine Rosen in THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. "In a charming if meandering style, she samples from her conversations with traditional librarians and with ‘cybrarians,’ a catch-all term for a generation of librarians intent on finding ways to integrate the old mission of the library with the new possibilities of technology. A good observer with a keen eye for detail, Ms. Johnson...succeeds in making us like librarians.” Read more.
THE BOSTON GLOBE wrote, "As Johnson amply shows in her romp through the brave new world of the profession, [the] new librarians cum information scientists are building on the work of their pioneering predecessors as they branch out in sometimes surprising directions.” Read more.
Overdue was one of the hot reads at THE DAILY BEAST, which called it "A stirring defense of the role of librarians in our Internet Age."
"Librarians have a champion in Johnson, yet her clear bias takes nothing away from the book, partly because she builds a solid case for their existence," wrote Kim Ode in the THE STAR TRIBUNE. "This is where librarians are our best allies, and Johnson thankfully adopts a 'show, don't tell' approach. She takes us behind the reference desk to witness the shift to an online digital catalog (not a pretty sight); introduces us to the often cynical world of librarians who blog (InfoFetishist, Obnoxious Librarian from Hades); reveals the heretofore unimagined challenge of poop in the library (really!), and interviews the "Street Librarians" at the 2008 Republican National Convention in St. Paul who decided that, as masters of reference material, they could be of some service, whether to protesters or politicians." Read more.
"Johnson’s exquisite book taps into the radical changes that libraries are going through," wrote Dylan Foley of the NEWARK STAR-LEDGER. "She blows apart the librarian stereotypes of stiff, prim matrons. Librarians have blogs now, some have extensive tattoos and funky haircuts, but in Johnson’s eyes, they are still committed 'intellectual social workers,' educating whoever comes through their doors in the face of brutal budget cuts." Read more.
CONFESSIONS OF AN IDIOSYNCRATIC MIND made This Book Is Overdue! a Pick of the Week, writing: "I don't go to the library enough, but Johnson's paean to the institution - and the range of people, from old-school types dragged into the present to punk-haired, social media-savvy types loudly getting out the word, who are both bound up and pushing hard against tradition - is a swift boot in the rear reminder why I, and others, should do the exact opposite of ignoring them. From free speech to scatologocal tales, personal stories to larger themes, THIS BOOK IS OVERDUE! is, well, very much overdue." Read more.
The wonderful site, BOOKPAGE, gave a ringing endorsement to the GLORIOUSLY GEEKY Overdue. Reviewer Amy Scribner wrote: "Energetic, winningly acerbic and DOWNRIGHT FUN, This Book is Overdue will leave you convinced that librarians really can save the world."
PUBLISHERS WEEKLY gave This Book Is Overdue! a STARRED REVIEW that praises the book for "illuminating the state of the modern librarian with humor and authority" and concludes, "Johnson’s wry report is A MUST-READ for anyone who’s used a library in the past quarter century."
O MAGAZINE gave This Book Is Overdue!a wonderful review in their February issue. "This is a book for readers who know that words can be wild and dangerous, that uncensored access to information is a right and a privilege, and that the attempt to 'catalog the world in all its complexity' is heroic beyond compare."
LIBRARY JOURNAL agreed that this book about cutting-edge librarians was overdue. They gave it an extraordinary welcome, posting a set of video interviews in the issue with an enthusiastic review. The reviewer, Donna L. Davey, a librarian at NYU, wrote that "Librarians and archivists, in all their eccentric, tech-savvy, and service-oriented glory, are celebrated in this highly complimentary and lively survey of their professions and THIS SPIRITED BOOK WILL BE ENJOYED BY ALL WHO LOVE LIBRARIES, or are poised to discover their value."
In an earlier issue, the editor-in-chief of LIBRARY JOURNAL, Francine Fialkoff, wrote: "Just in time to lift the dispirited, a forthcoming book by a nonlibrarian captures the breathtaking transformations in the field in recent years and those responsible for them. Journalist Marilyn Johnson, a former Life and Esquire staffer and an obit expert (The Dead Beat, HarperCollins), makes a case for becoming a librarian in her kaleidoscopic This Book Is Overdue: How Librarians and Cybrarians Can Save Us All (HarperCollins, Feb. 2010). She ferrets out the blogs and bloggers; dives into cataloging, systems, Second Life, and digital collections and delivery; attends the opening of the new Darien Library; and hangs out with the Connecticut Four, who challenged the Patriot Act, and the Desk Set, a group of young, funny, smart New York librarians who raise money for literacy, among other things...WHO KNEW librarianship and LIBRARIANS WERE SO COOL, other than us insiders?"
And Barbara Hoffert's Prepub Alert in LIBRARY JOURNAL declared, "Johnson, bless her heart, argues that in the Age of Google, librarians are more important than ever. And she tells the story of a bunch of cutting-edge 'cybrarians' to make the point. With a 40,000-copy first printing; not bad!"
EARLYWORD told librarians heading to their convention, "If you have time to hunt down just one galley at MidWinter, go directly to HarperCollins’ booth for This Book is Overdue! And, overdue it is; finally, a book written for a general audience that gives librarians the respect we deserve and recognizes how important, rather than irrelevant, we are in the digital age."
BOOKLIST gave This Book Is Overdue! a fine welcome. "Johnson’s paean to this new generation of librarians demolishes superannuated myths and stereotypes of fusty librarians filing catalog cards and collecting fines for overdue books, and replaces that with a vision of the profession’s future where librarians serve as guardians and guides to information in cyberspace," writes Mark Knoblauch. "These ROCK STAR LIBRARIANS maneuver their way through a labyrinthine network of glowing computer-terminal screens to retrieve whatever answers patrons may seek. If that’s not high calling enough, librarians stand tall as superhero sentinels bravely beating back every assault on civil liberties and Constitutional government." Rock-star librarians-- sweet!
And Vanessa Bush, whose Minority Report blog appears on the BOOKLIST site, wrote, "I was thrilled to read the review of This Book is Overdue! How Librarians and Cybrarians Can Save Us All by Marilyn Johnson and see how the image of librarians may be shifting into cool."
Check out the fantastic review from Jenna Freedman in her LOWER EAST SIDE LIBRARIAN blog. Freedman is the subject of the chapter "To the Ramparts!" but that was no guarantee of her enthusiasm, and I know she was alarmed at the idea of a book about librarians that had no index. This pales in light of all the things she thinks the book got right, like: "So often people wax on about libraries being so great, vs. librarians. As if the former could really be anything without the labor of the latter. Not Johnson, and I appreciate that! You'll want to just kiss her for this quote, 'So when I hear this snarky question (and I hear it everywhere): Are librarians obsolete in the Age of Google? All I can say is, are you kidding?...'"
I did, by the way, promise her an online index to the book. I'm working on it!
This Book Is Overdue! "documents in a VIVID AND WITTY style how libraries are changing (and struggling to change) to meet the demands and expectations of digital-age consumers," according to Richard James of DELAWARE LIBRARIES, and was "amazing to read."
"...here in book form is the appreciation that information professionals have long needed and long deserved," wrote Birdie at LISNEWS in a sweet review that concluded "...with the finely-tuned ability of an investigative journalist, Johnson shows us the stories behind the story and the vibrant and unique personalities behind the buns, beards, tattoos and cardigan sweaters."
"...this is something that everyone needs to know about...the book that every librarian needs to buy–yes, buy; and also gift to every friend and family member you have," says The Librarienne at CLOSED STACKS before her interview. Thanks, Librarienne!
"In a time of economic stress, when librarians are needed more than ever, yet library budgets are being cut, Marilyn Johnson speaks out in our behalf in her forthcoming book This Book Is Overdue: How Librarians and Cybrarians Can Save Us All. Her message to anyone who will listen is that librarians are the 'authors of opportunity,'" reported Rick Roche in his blog RICKLIBRARIAN. He mentioned his favorite chapters in this "long anticipated" and "always fair" book, and recommended it to colleagues. "Her praises" of the profession, he noted, "greatly overshadow her criticisms."
"Marilyn Johnson has gone to our conferences, interviewed us, raised a glass with us, and visited us virtually. And now she’s here at THE DESK SET to answer five questions, plus a bonus round, about her forthcoming book." The Desk Set blog is all over This Book Is Overdue! in a Q and A between Jessica Pigza (one of the librarians featured in the book) and the author called, appropriately, "This Interview Is Early."
THE DEAD BEAT
"This delightful quirk of a book is not dark or morose; it's an uplifting, joyous, life-affirming read for people who ordinarily steer clear of uplifting, joyous, life-affirming reads….Of all the personalities captured in 'The Dead Beat,' few are more endearing than Johnson, a former obituary writer. Her enthusiasm is infectious.…Writers interested in honing the craft should inhale this book. Who else might profit or delight from reading about obituaries? Just about anyone who's not yet in one, I'd wager."
The Los Angeles Times
"In The Dead Beat, Marilyn Johnson - an obituarist herself - acts as our Virgil through the back pages, introducing the knowledgeable, eccentric and talented writers responsible for sending off the just and the unjust, the famous and the not-so-famous."
The Observer (London)
"...while Johnson's analysis of the form and its top practitioners is absorbing, her account of the culture of obituary lovers is downright amazing."
--Jane and Michael Stern
The NY Times Book Review
NPR's Morning Edition
**** (4 stars)
"....a smart, tart and
often hilarious tiptoe
through the tombstones."
"I think it will be the sleeper book of the year."
The Boston Globe
"A fetching book about obituaries? Well, yes:
Ms. Johnson writes about obituaries with the
zeal--and insight--of an avid obit fan."
The New York Times
"If you have ever, once, reveled in the obit page, you'll be reading aloud from these fan's notes by a former Life obit writer. She's been obsessively clipping for years and shares the choice shockers and tearjerkers -- along with an infectious reverence for the form. Only irresistible lives live here."
"Open this enormously entertaining book and your life will contain three certainties: death, taxes and an overwhelming desire to turn the pages."
The San Diego Union-Tribune
"The Dead Beat is a romp of a book that captures with well-placed humor the curious assortment of people featured in the obits, as well as those who write them, read them, collect them and - well - simply are obsessed with them."
--Verna Noel Jones
The Rocky Mountain News
"Marilyn Johnson shares her obsession in exuberant and elegiac style."
The Baltimore Sun
"What Marilyn Johnson thought would be 'a little cult book' is turning into one of the most admired books of the season."
The Connecticut Post
"If you've ever wanted to know the secrets behind the obituary - and there are some juicy, fascinating ones to be had - Marilyn Johnson's wonderful 'The Dead Beat' (HarperCollins) is the book for you."
"Marilyn Johnson is such a beautiful writer, and is so at ease and funny about the forbidden subject of death, that you find yourself cheering when the obit writer gets it right and the dead person gets his due."
Publishers Weekly Q & A
"Marilyn Johnson's new book The Dead Beat is an epiphany of epiphanies of epiphanies. Her writing, like good poetry, opens your eyes to see the extraordinary in the ordinary to the degree that you have to wonder where her sizeable skills end and where grace begins....Ms. Johnson reminds us, to riff on a line from Thomas Merton, that all of these ordinary folks walk around blind to themselves but shining like the sun."
"...This is a jewel of a book joyfully free of typographical and grammatical errors..."
--a reader on Amazon.com